Leveraging Local Dynamics and Sustainable Partnerships
China’s Influence in Zambia: Not as Coordinated as It Seems
China’s growing presence in Africa has long been a subject of intense scrutiny. In exchange for resources and influence, China provides African nations with significant financial support and infrastructure. However, as our extensive research into Zambia’s experience shows, China’s success in the region is not as coordinated or monolithic as often portrayed.
Zambia: A Case Study in Chinese Influence
China’s role in Zambia, a country rich in copper and other natural resources, exemplifies its broader approach to Africa. Beijing has invested heavily in infrastructure projects, ranging from roads to power plants, which have bolstered Zambia’s development. However, Zambians’ views of China are far from universally positive. The influence China exerts is layered with complexities, and there are significant cracks in the narrative of Chinese dominance.
One key misconception is that China’s influence in Zambia is uniform and entirely state-directed. On the contrary, a large number of small Chinese business operators in Zambia have distanced themselves from the state-owned enterprises (SOEs) and the overarching control of the Chinese government. These small entrepreneurs sought opportunities in Zambia for more autonomy and to escape an overbearing party-state. As the ancient Chinese proverb goes, “The mountains are high, and the emperor is far away,” illustrating how these operators often feel disconnected from China’s centralized authority.
Internal Divisions: Resentment Among Chinese Operators
Tensions between small Chinese businesses and larger state-controlled enterprises are another important factor to consider. These smaller operators, many of whom resent the dominance of larger, more influential Chinese companies, often struggle to compete on an unequal playing field. This internal division weakens China’s overall position in Zambia, providing an opportunity for other international players to contest Beijing’s influence.
Opportunities for the United States and Other Countries
The fissures in China’s approach to Zambia open doors for the U.S. and other nations. The perception that Chinese investment is all-encompassing and uncontested is misleading. Western nations can capitalize on these tensions by offering alternatives that appeal to Zambians who are wary of China’s dominance. Initiatives that emphasize sustainable development, local job creation, and transparent business practices could sway public opinion and drive interest away from Beijing’s projects.
However, the consequence of Western inaction is clear: China will continue to solidify its hold over Zambia’s resources and economic infrastructure. If Washington and its allies hope to challenge Beijing’s influence, now is the time to act.
Generalizing Lessons from Zambia
While Zambia presents a unique case, its experience with China offers insights applicable to other African nations. Across the continent, many countries are navigating a similar balancing act—welcoming Chinese investment while grappling with its long-term costs and consequences. The divisions within China’s approach, whether between small and large businesses or between state and non-state actors, are opportunities that can be exploited. For the West, the lesson is clear: Africa is not lost to China, and there are openings for influence—if they are seized.
At Invest Offshore, we believe in highlighting these investment dynamics, particularly in regions like West Africa, where the Copperbelt’s untapped potential presents unique opportunities. As China’s approach proves more fractured than assumed, Western investors have a chance to play a significant role in shaping the future of African development.
A U.S. Strategy for Zambia: Countering Chinese Influence and Strengthening Partnerships
As China’s engagement in Zambia continues to grow, the U.S. must develop a proactive strategy to counterbalance Beijing’s influence while fostering long-term partnerships in the region. Zambia, a key player in Africa’s resource-rich Copperbelt, presents both challenges and opportunities for American foreign policy and economic engagement. A successful U.S. strategy in Zambia should focus on the following key areas:
1. Promoting Sustainable Development
China’s investment in Zambia, while significant, often comes with strings attached—such as debt dependency and lack of local employment. The U.S. can distinguish itself by offering Zambia sustainable development models that focus on local capacity building and long-term economic benefits. U.S. projects should prioritize job creation, skills training, and the development of local industries, reducing Zambia’s dependency on raw material exports.
For example, promoting renewable energy projects, enhancing agricultural productivity, or supporting technology transfer for the local manufacturing sector could have a transformative impact on Zambia’s economy. By emphasizing transparency and sustainability, the U.S. can position itself as a partner that aligns with Zambian interests rather than simply extracting resources.
2. Offering Alternatives to Chinese Infrastructure Financing
One of China’s most visible impacts in Zambia is through its infrastructure investments. However, these projects often come with hefty financial obligations, pushing Zambia into significant debt. The U.S. can offer viable alternatives through institutions such as the Millennium Challenge Corporation (MCC), the International Development Finance Corporation (DFC), and USAID. These agencies can help provide lower-cost financing options for infrastructure development that avoids the debt traps associated with Chinese loans.
By collaborating with Zambian officials to prioritize infrastructure projects that are needed most—whether it’s roads, hospitals, or renewable energy grids—the U.S. can ensure that its investments benefit the local population and align with Zambia’s national development goals.
3. Enhancing Diplomatic and Security Engagement
The U.S. must also deepen its diplomatic and security ties with Zambia. This can be done by expanding military cooperation and intelligence-sharing in areas like counterterrorism and peacekeeping operations, as well as encouraging Zambia to engage with regional institutions like the Southern African Development Community (SADC).
Strengthening relationships at the diplomatic level can also give the U.S. more leverage when it comes to pushing for governance reforms or supporting Zambia’s democratic institutions. A focus on governance, human rights, and anti-corruption efforts would appeal to many Zambians who are wary of Chinese business practices and seek more accountable leadership.
4. Supporting Zambian Civil Society and Education
The U.S. has an opportunity to influence Zambian society through programs that support civil society organizations, educational exchanges, and media independence. Investments in these areas can help cultivate a generation of Zambian leaders who are critical of authoritarian models and more open to democratic governance.
In particular, the U.S. can expand Fulbright and similar exchange programs to build stronger people-to-people ties. Strengthening Zambia’s civil society—especially in areas like free press, human rights, and legal reforms—can act as a counterweight to the more transactional and state-centric approach of Chinese engagement.
5. Leveraging Zambia’s Economic Opportunities
Zambia’s economic potential, especially in mining, agriculture, and renewable energy, provides key areas for U.S. investment. The Copperbelt region, home to vast copper deposits, is central to the global demand for critical minerals needed for clean energy technologies. U.S. companies should be encouraged to invest in sustainable mining practices and supply chain transparency, positioning American businesses as ethical alternatives to Chinese firms.
Moreover, Zambia’s agricultural potential is vast, and U.S. agribusiness partnerships could play a significant role in boosting food security and rural livelihoods. By working with local farmers and entrepreneurs, the U.S. can help Zambia develop resilient supply chains that are less dependent on foreign imports.
6. Exploiting Internal Divisions Among Chinese Operators
As demonstrated by the situation in Zambia, China’s influence is not monolithic. Many smaller Chinese businesses operate with autonomy and often resent larger state-owned enterprises. The U.S. can exploit these divisions by promoting partnerships with these smaller operators who may prefer working within the more transparent and rule-of-law-oriented frameworks that American businesses can offer.
7. Strengthening Regional Engagement
Finally, the U.S. must view its strategy in Zambia through a regional lens. Zambia is an integral part of Southern Africa, and any efforts to engage with Zambia should be tied to broader strategies that include neighboring countries such as Angola, Mozambique, and the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). A regional approach will also help ensure that Zambia’s stability and prosperity contribute to a more peaceful and integrated Southern African region.
Conclusion
The U.S. has a real opportunity to develop a strategy in Zambia that goes beyond merely reacting to China’s presence. By promoting sustainable development, offering alternatives to Chinese financing, and deepening diplomatic and economic engagement, the U.S. can reshape its role in Zambia for mutual benefit. The competition for influence in Zambia—and Africa more broadly—is not a foregone conclusion, and with a well-crafted strategy, the U.S. can effectively contest China’s dominance and foster stronger, more equitable partnerships in the region.
Leave a Reply